The Premier League match between Arsenal and Newcastle United witnessed a stunning development. Leaked VAR audio revealed why Bruno Guimaraes avoided a red card. The match already stirred controversy, particularly with Anthony Gordon‘s goal and the avoidance of red cards by Guimaraes and Kai Havertz. Moreover, this insight into the VAR process is likely to astonish Arsenal and football fans alike.
This Premier League encounter was marked by contentious VAR decisions. Anthony Gordon’s goal went through several reviews. Additionally, the incidents involving Guimaraes and Havertz, who seemed to avoid red cards, sparked debate. PGMOL later affirmed the correctness of Gordon’s goal. Yet, details about Guimaraes and Havertz’s incidents remained unknown until now.
Inside the VAR Room: Guimaraes Incident Unveiled
The focus of the VAR discussions was Bruno Guimaraes’ late contact with Jorginho using his arm. Moreover, the leaked audio captures VAR officials Andy Madley and assistant Stuart Burt, and referee Stuart Atwell discussing Guimaraes’ conduct.
Madley initiated the discussion, focusing on the intent behind Guimaraes’ actions. Moreover, he assessed whether Guimaraes aimed to harm Jorginho. Burt agreed with Madley, suggesting that while Guimaraes’ actions were unsavory, they didn’t warrant a red card. Furthermore, both officials concluded that it was a yellow card offense.
Madley ended the discussion, deciding that Guimaraes’ actions didn’t merit a red card. This decision has sparked debate after the audio leak.
The Bigger Picture: Controversial VAR Decisions
The Independent Key Match Incidents Panel reviewed the Guimaraes and Havertz incidents. They believed both players deserved red cards. The decision on Guimaraes was split. However, it was unanimous on Havertz’s case. This has stirred discussions about VAR’s reliability in the Premier League.
The panel’s differing view on Guimaraes’ actions questions VAR’s effectiveness. Inconsistencies in VAR decisions have long frustrated fans, players, and managers. PGMOL chief Howard Webb admitted the oversight in officiating. This has added to the debate about VAR’s transparency and accountability.
These developments have intensified discussions about VAR reform and technology in football. The leaked audio highlights the complexities of VAR decision-making, prompting calls for more clarity and consistency in its application.
For more sports updates, follow us on Twitter.